Anthropic Gave Away MCP. The Protocols That Touch Money Will Not Follow.

An open-source licence is not neutral governance. Payments learned that difference forty years ago.

Share
Anthropic Gave Away MCP. The Protocols That Touch Money Will Not Follow.

A standard owned by one participant is a competitive instrument. Payments learned that forty years ago. The agentic payment protocols have not.

On 9 December, Anthropic donated the Model Context Protocol to the Agentic AI Foundation, a directed fund under the Linux Foundation co-founded with Block and OpenAI, and supported by Google, Microsoft, AWS, Cloudflare and Bloomberg.

MCP is not a payments protocol. It is how an application exposes its capabilities to an AI model — tools, data, context. There is no money in it.

So why is this the most consequential governance event of the year for agentic payments?

Because it is the first time anybody in this ecosystem has done the thing that actually makes a standard into infrastructure: given up control of it.

And the payments industry, of all industries, should recognise why that matters, because we learned it the hard way and a long time ago.

What we already know about standards

Every payments standard that became universal has one property in common: nobody owns it.

EMV exists because three competing networks put it into a jointly governed body. The specification is not Visa's or Mastercard's; it is EMVCo's, and that is precisely why an EMV terminal in São Paulo accepts a card issued in Seoul. ISO 8583 and ISO 20022 are international standards maintained by a neutral body, which is why they became the message formats of the entire industry rather than the message formats of whoever published them.

Now consider the counter-examples, which are more instructive. Every proprietary payment standard that stayed proprietary ended up as a product with a market share rather than a standard with a universe. The owner always faces the same temptation — to tilt the specification toward its own commercial interest — and competitors, knowing the temptation exists, decline to build on it.

That is not cynicism about any particular company. It is structural. A standard controlled by a participant in the market it governs is a competitive instrument, and everyone treats it as one whether or not the owner ever abuses it. The suspicion alone is enough to prevent adoption.

Where that leaves the agentic payment protocols

Hold the agentic protocols up against that standard and the picture is uncomfortable.

ACP was open-sourced by OpenAI and Stripe. Open source is a licence, not a governance structure. The copyright holders still decide what goes in the next version, and one of them charges merchants a fee on purchases completed through it.

AP2 was published by Google with more than sixty supporting companies. Sixty supporters is adoption, not governance. The specification is still Google's to steer.

x402 has an actual foundation, established by Coinbase with Cloudflare. That is genuinely closer to neutral than the other two, and it deserves credit for it. Whether a foundation co-founded by the protocol's author counts as independent governance is a question that gets answered over years, not at launch.

MCP has now been donated outright to a Linux Foundation fund, with three co-founding companies that compete with each other and five more large firms supporting it.

Only one of those four has given away the thing that makes ownership valuable.

And here is the part I would not skip if I were assessing this honestly: MCP was the easiest one to donate. Anthropic sells models. It does not monetise MCP directly. Giving away a protocol you do not charge for costs you influence and nothing else.

ACP is a much harder case, because OpenAI takes a fee on completed purchases that flow through it. AP2 sits adjacent to a commerce business of enormous size. The closer a protocol sits to the money, the more its ownership is worth — and therefore the less likely it is to be given away, and the more it needs to be.

That is the uncomfortable symmetry at the centre of this. The protocols most in need of neutral governance are the ones whose owners have the strongest reason to retain it.

The governance detail that makes it work

One thing in the announcement is worth isolating, because it answers the objection that usually kills a donation like this.

The Agentic AI Foundation's governing board decides on strategic investment, budget, member recruitment and approval of new projects. But individual projects, in the announcement's own words, maintain full autonomy over their technical direction and day-to-day operations. The people who already steward MCP continue to make its decisions, through the existing community process, and the Linux Foundation states it will not dictate the technical direction of MCP.

Anthropic, for its part, says it will continue to invest in development, maintain core infrastructure and participate in the community.

That structure matters because the standard objection to donating a protocol is that it will stagnate — the sponsor loses interest, the foundation has no engineers, and the specification quietly stops moving. Separating the money and membership questions from the technical direction, while the original sponsor keeps funding the work, is the arrangement that has historically avoided that outcome.

Whether it works here is a question for 2027. But it is the right shape, and it is a more carefully designed one than the headline suggests.

From a Mexico City desk

Two things follow from this for institutions in this region, and the first is unusually actionable.

A foundation has a door. This is the part I keep coming back to.

I have written before that the agentic standards are being designed in rooms where nobody from this region is present, and that this is not malice — standards get built by whoever shows up. The problem has been that there was nowhere to show up to. You cannot join a specification published by a company. There is no membership, no board, no process. You can adopt it or not.

A Linux Foundation directed fund has members. It has a governing board with a recruitment process. It is, structurally, the first agentic standards body that a Latin American payments association, a regional processor or a central bank could actually join.

Whether that is worth doing is a judgment about cost and benefit. But it is now a decision rather than an impossibility, and as far as I can tell nobody in this region has noticed that it changed.

And MCP is going to reach our systems before any payment protocol does. This is the quieter point and the one with a budget attached.

MCP is becoming the way a system exposes what it can do to an AI agent. Not a payment — a capability. Which means that within about two years, the question of how an agent reaches a core banking platform, a card management system, a dispute workflow or a fraud console will be answered by something MCP-shaped.

That is an architecture decision, and it will arrive as a vendor roadmap item rather than as a strategy discussion. The institutions that think about it early will choose what they expose and under what controls. The ones that do not will have it chosen for them by whichever supplier ships an integration first.

I would rather be in the first group, and the way to be in the first group is to have an opinion before the roadmap arrives.

My judgment

The most mature governance decision in agentic AI this year came from the layer furthest from the money, and that is not a coincidence.

Donating a protocol is cheap when you do not monetise it and expensive when you do. MCP was the easy case, which takes nothing away from the fact that it was done properly — outright donation, neutral host, competing co-founders, technical autonomy preserved, continued investment committed.

My prediction, offered so it can be checked: none of the agentic payment protocols will follow within twelve months. Not ACP, which carries a fee. Not AP2, which sits beside a commerce business. The economics point the other way, and the ecosystem will go on confusing an open-source licence with neutral governance because the distinction is inconvenient.

What would change my mind is a single event: ACP donated to a body OpenAI does not control. If that happens, agentic commerce has a real standard and the industry can build on it the way it built on EMV. Until then it has a specification published by a company that takes a cut of the transactions flowing through it, and we should all be clear-eyed that those are different things.

Three questions for the people who own this

1. Of the agentic protocols your vendors are proposing to support, which are governed by a body the author does not control? If the answer is none, what is your institution's exposure if the specification turns in a direction that suits its owner and not you?

2. When an agent needs to reach your core platform, your card management system or your dispute workflow, who in your institution decides what gets exposed and under what controls? If the answer is the vendor, that decision has already been made.

3. The Agentic AI Foundation has a membership process. Has anyone in your market — your processor, your banking association, your regulator — looked at what joining would cost and what it would buy? If nobody has looked, the answer to whether we are in the room stays the same as it has been.

Reply to this email with a line or two. The sharpest answers will shape the next issue.

Sources

Model Context Protocol blog, 9 December 2025 — Anthropic donates MCP to the Agentic AI Foundation, a directed fund under the Linux Foundation co-founded with Block and OpenAI and supported by Google, Microsoft, AWS, Cloudflare and Bloomberg; MCP joins Block's goose and OpenAI's AGENTS.md as founding projects; the governing board's remit over strategic investment, budget, member recruitment and approval of new projects; the statement that individual projects maintain full autonomy over their technical direction and day-to-day operations, that existing maintainers continue to decide through the community process, and that the Linux Foundation will not dictate MCP's technical direction; and Anthropic's commitment to continue investing in development, maintaining core infrastructure and participating in the community. Link

This is the project's own announcement. The comparison with EMVCo and ISO standards, the assessment of ACP, AP2 and x402 governance, and the argument that proximity to revenue makes a protocol less likely to be donated are mine. No company quoted above has made any of those claims, and I hold no position in any of them.